Property valuation: how German banks calculate the mortgage lending value and the property value under the CRR
“The bank values the property at less than I am paying.” We hear this more often than any other concern in an initial consultation, and it is correct. The difference follows banking regulation rather than negotiation.
This three-page guide explains the calculation with a worked example, so you can assess your equity requirement before signing the purchase contract.
Why does a bank's property valuation come in below the purchase price?
Because the purchase price is what you pay today, while the lending value is what the property is expected to be worth across the whole life of the loan; § 16 (2) Pfandbrief Act rules out speculative elements. Article 229 CRR III requires a prudent value. For let properties the income value caps it too (§ 4 (1) BelWertV).
What does the bank valuation guide cover?
- Three values that are often confused. Market value, lending value and property value side by side — with the most common misunderstanding: the property value is not a further deduction from the lending value but the requirement a value has to meet.
- What changed on 1 January 2025. Article 229 CRR III removed the choice between market value and lending value. Expected price increases no longer count, market value is the ceiling, and existing loans are being converted by the end of 2027.
- A worked example. €500,000 purchase price, €20,000 annual rent: gross income, operating costs, net income, multiplier and income value line by line with the source for each step — result €232,364, or 46 % of the price. Next to it the second permitted route at €450,000.
- Why the rate is the lever. The purchase price is 25 times the annual rent. The approximately 2.8 % refers to net income: the original factsheet deducts €6,068 operating costs from €20,000 annual rent, leaving €13,932; relative to the €500,000 purchase price, that is about 2.8 %. The bank has to calculate with at least 5.5 %. Double the rate means roughly half the value.
- What we can influence — and what we cannot. Set out in a table: the minimum rate is in the regulation, the choice of institution is our work.
- Four points before you sign. To tick off, including the question about the simplified procedure for loans up to €600,000 (§ 24 BelWertV).
Request by email: Briefing note on bank valuation 2026 (PDF, 3 pages) (Dutch (bankwaarde))
Request the briefing note
What would you like to receive?
We use your email address to send the files you request. If needed, we may contact you personally about your request.
How much does the bank valuation guide cost?
Nothing. The PDF opens straight away, without a form. Bilingual (German and English), three pages with sample calculations. Work it out for yourself.
Why is the mortgage lending value lower than the purchase price? The two figures answer different questions. The purchase price is what you pay for the property today.
The mortgage value is the value that the property is expected to retain over the entire term of the loan — speculative elements are expressly excluded under Section 16(2) of the Pfandbrief Act (PfandBG).
The difference follows prudential regulation rather than negotiation.
Since 1 January 2025, Article 229 of CRR III has required a conservative value to be used for capital adequacy purposes; the previous option to choose between market value and mortgage lending value no longer applies.
In the case of let properties, the income value (§ 4(1) BelWertV), capitalised at a rate of at least 5.5 % (§ 12(4) BelWertV), also acts as a cap — this is where the gap between the income value and the purchase price is greatest.
You cannot negotiate the calculation itself, but you can choose the bank. The two permitted valuation methods can produce significantly different values for the same property. The free guide illustrates the difference with a worked example.
- 650+ banks compared
- §34i Licensed adviser
- 2016 Experience since
- 89 Published case reports
How do the market, lending and property values differ?
The market value is what could be achieved on the valuation date, roughly your purchase price; the lending value is what remains achievable over the whole life of the loan.
The property value is not a further deduction, but the requirement a value has to meet.
| Value | What it reflects |
|---|---|
| Market value | What could be achieved on the valuation date — roughly your purchase price. |
| Mortgage lending value | What remains achievable over the whole life of the loan; speculative elements are excluded (§ 16 (2) PfandBG). |
| Property value (CRR III) | Not a third, lower figure but the requirement a value must meet: no expected price increases, never above market value. The BelWertV lending value meets it in every case according to the national supervisor; alternatively the bank takes the market value and applies a deduction. |
Let properties: how does the bank calculate the value?
From the income value, which caps the lending value. In the worked example, €20,000 annual net cold rent at a 5.5 % capitalisation rate and 40 years remaining useful life give €232,364, about 46 % of the €500,000 purchase price.
- Gross income: annual net cold rent €20,000 — sustainably achievable · § 10 BelWertV
- Land value €75,000 · § 9 (2) BelWertV
- 5.5 % capitalisation rate, 40 years remaining useful life · § 12 BelWertV
- Income value — the cap: €232,364 — about 46 % of the €500,000 purchase price · § 4 (1) BelWertV
This worked example follows the regulation. It is a model calculation with assumed inputs, not a financing commitment for a specific property.
The second permitted route, market value less a deduction, would give about €450,000 for the same property.
What is not negotiable in a valuation?
It helps nobody if a broker promises more than the regulation allows. Three things are settled before the first conversation begins: (1) the minimum capitalisation rate of 5.5 % for residential use (§ 12 (4) BelWertV), (2) that expected increases in value do not count (Article 229 CRR III) and (3) the income value as the cap on let properties (§ 4 (1) BelWertV).
The minimum capitalisation rate: It is set in § 12 (4) BelWertV and published by BaFin — 5.5 % for residential use, 6.5 % commercial, unchanged since 1 January 2024. Only prime properties may go up to 0.5 percentage points lower, and only where eight criteria are met at once.
What is the minimum capitalisation rate (Mindestkapitalisierungszins), and who sets it?
It is set out in Section 12(4) of the BelWertV and is published by the BaFin — 5.5 % for residential use, 6.5 % for commercial use, unchanged since 1 January 2024.
Only in the case of first-class properties may the rate be set at up to 0.5 percentage points below this level, and only if eight criteria are met simultaneously.
The fact that expected increases in value do not count: This is Article 229 of CRR III. What the market might bring is not taken into account — even if prices in the street have demonstrably risen.
The capitalised income value as a cap for let properties: Section 4(1) of the BelWertV states explicitly: “The capitalised income value is generally the basis for determining the mortgage lending value and must not be exceeded.” The asset value is determined separately, but serves only for verification purposes.
What can you influence in the valuation process?
Three factors make a difference: the institution you choose, your documentation and your financing structure. The lending value under the BelWertV and the market value with a deduction can produce markedly different figures.
- The choice of institution: Since 2025 two routes are recognised: the lending value under the BelWertV — or the market value with a deduction. Both are permitted, and for the same property they produce markedly different figures. Which route an institution takes decides the loan amount that is possible. A broker helps you identify the right lender.
- The documentation: What is not evidenced is not counted. Documented refurbishment extends the remaining useful life and so lifts the income value directly. A stated rent without a contract, by contrast, counts for nothing.
- The structure: Transaction costs from own funds, splitting across several securities, using a property you already own — all of that changes the loan-to-value without touching the value itself. And it is the ratio that sets your rate bracket.
You can run your own property through the lending value calculator — both routes side by side.
Which parts of the structure change the loan-to-value ratio without changing the property value?
Paying purchase costs from your own funds, spreading the loan across several forms of security or using a property you already own can change the loan-to-value ratio without changing the property value. This ratio determines the interest rate band.
You can work out for yourself what the bank might value your property at using the Mortgage Value Calculator — comparing both methods side by side.
Bank valuation: what should you clarify before signing?
Four points: ask for the lending value up front, budget transaction costs from own funds, evidence the rent roll, areas and refurbishment, and for loans up to €600,000 ask about the simplified procedure.
- Ask for the lending value up front: Beforehand it is a question of which bank; afterwards it is your equity gap.
- Budget transaction costs from own funds: Transfer tax, notary, land registry and agent fees are no security for the bank.
- Evidence the rent roll, areas and refurbishment: Invoices and contractor declarations feed into the value through the remaining useful life.
- For loans up to €600,000 ask about the simplified procedure: § 24 BelWertV then allows the full appraisal to be waived — saving time and cost, with the valuation rules unchanged.
How do we help with the bank valuation?
Before applying, we calculate your property value using both permitted methods and look for a bank whose valuation method suits the case. The regulatory requirements remain binding. Which bank accepts your financing is still decided individually.
Frequently asked questions
Why does the bank calculate with less than the purchase price?
Because the purchase price is what you pay today, while the lending value is what holds over the whole life of the loan. § 16 (2) of the German Pfandbrief Act rules out speculative elements outright. Since 1 January 2025 Article 229 CRR III has additionally required a prudent value for capital purposes.
Can the lending value be negotiated?
The value itself, no — the parameters are set in the Mortgage Lending Value Regulation and the minimum capitalisation rate is published by BaFin. Three other things are open to influence: the choice of institution, the completeness of your documentation and the structure of the financing.
Why is the gap widest on let properties?
Because there the income value governs under § 4 (1) BelWertV and has to be capitalised at a minimum of 5.5 % (§ 12 (4) BelWertV). The price equals 25 times the annual rent. The roughly 2.8 % relates to the factsheet’s €13,932 net income after €6,068 operating costs, divided by the €500,000 purchase price. Double the rate means roughly half the value.
What changes on a follow-up financing?
Existing loans are being converted to the prudent value by the end of 2027. A fresh valuation can push your loan-to-value up even though you have been repaying — which is why follow-up financing belongs on the table early, not in the final year.
Is the briefing note available to take away?
Yes — three pages as a PDF, bilingual German and English, with a worked example. It opens directly or can be requested by email.
Renegotiating a loan: what can be negotiated with the bank, and what cannot?
Nothing in the bank’s lending value calculation is negotiable; it follows supervisory law, and the minimum capitalisation rate is set out in § 12 (4) BelWertV (5.5 % for residential use).
What can be shaped is the choice of bank, the completeness of the documents and the structure of the financing. For the same house, the two permitted valuation methods lead to markedly different values.
Any questions on this topic?
A first consultation is free and without obligation — the commission is, as a rule, paid by the bank. We tell you what this means for your own financing.
For a property loan, most banks only arrive at a workable calculation from a household net income of around €3,500 a month — for couples, the joint income counts.
Share the agreed price, any bank valuation and the amount you need to borrow. We can assess how the lender’s valuation affects the deposit you need.
